VOLKSWAGEN-LAW/“I hope the next three months will be better for you than the last three,” Czech ambassador Jaromir Novotny told a gathering of Japanese car importers last month.

The way things are going, he’ll be hoping against hope.

In April, Japan introduced an “eco-car” tax incentive that has left all foreign car brands such as Volkswagen, Mercedes-Benz and BMW, neatly outside the fence of eligibility.

It’s the last thing they need in a market that’s already full of quirks that make life difficult for non-Japanese car brands: the existence of a huge and unique 660cc microcar segment, convoluted recycling laws and stringent regulations against what type of materials can be used in fuel tanks, to name just a few.

No one is complaining about incentivising low-emission cars. But what rankles outsiders is that the perks are based on an outdated fuel economy testing method that critics say is a poor reflection of real-life driving.

“It’s so far from reality that we never bothered to tune our cars to get good readings under this method,” an executive at a European carmaker told me. “And now they’ve hit us with this eco-car tax and even if we wanted to make the adjustments, it would take us until next year to be ready.”

AUTOS/

Japan’s mileage test is based on cars with engines already warmed up, a very slow acceleration and a top speed of just 70 kph (43 mph) –  slow even for Japan, where the speed limit on highways is 100 kph.

The differences mean Toyota’s third-generation Prius gets listed fuel economy of 38 km/litre, or 89 mpg, in Japan, but only 50 mpg in the United States.

Granted, that still beats anything in its class hands down, but there’s another catch: fuel economy and emissions standards in Japan are divided into nine different weight classes, and designed in such a way that a relatively big car with a smallish engine scores well in each category.

Unfortunately for European cars, that’s pretty much the reverse of their general strategy for Japan: “a big, sexy engine in a small car relative to its weight”, as one industry expert described it to me.

To be fair, it wouldn’t be the first time that a country formulated its regulations to suit domestic companies.

But there must be questions when a Volkswagen Golf, known the world over as a fuel-efficient car, doesn’t qualify for the green tax rates when a big, honking van like Toyota’s Alphard does.

Photo credits: REUTERS/Christian Charisius; REUTERS/Lucas Jackson

Sphere: Related Content